U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton on Wednesday blocked some of the toughest provisions in the Arizona illegal immigration law, putting on hold the state's attempt to have local police enforce federal immigration policy.
Though the rest of the law is still set to go into effect Thursday, the partial injunction on SB 1070 means Arizona, for the time being, will not be able to require police officers to determine the immigration status of anyone they stop or arrest. Also struck down was the section of law that makes it a crime not to carry immigration registration papers and the provision that makes it a crime for an illegal immigrant to seek or perform work.
Some text from the ruling:
"The Court also finds that the United States is likely to suffer irreparable harm if the Court does not preliminarily enjoin enforcement of these Sections of S.B. 1070 and that the balance of equities tips in the United States’ favor considering the public interest."
"The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has stated 'that an alleged constitutional infringement will often alone constitute irreparable harm.'"
"The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has concluded that allowing a state to enforce a state law in violation of the Supremacy Clause is neither equitable nor in the public interest."
Related posts
Comments
7/30/2010 4:05:48 AM #
I'm not surprised that Federal law trumps State law.
Harrison | Reply
7/31/2010 5:39:53 AM #
I think some of her ruling will be thrown out by the supreme court.
Trestin Meacham | Reply
7/31/2010 1:51:03 PM #
If the Federal government would do their job, there would be no need for this law. Other states are not upset by this, they are going full steam ahead with their similar laws. At least 30 states so far.
Debbie | Reply
7/31/2010 8:32:37 PM #
They, too, will be overturned I think. As they should.
8/4/2010 2:17:29 AM #
Exactly right Debbie, the more states that jump on this bandwagon the better.
Brad | Reply
8/1/2010 11:24:53 AM #
I sadly figured this would be the result as soon as I found out that the judge was a woman.
Karen Howes | Reply
8/4/2010 2:18:01 AM #
Damn women... Just kidding ;)
8/2/2010 8:50:57 AM #
Pingback from conservativehideout.com Sunday Linkage, and Where did that car Company go? | Conservative Hideout 2.0
conservativehideout.com | Reply
8/4/2010 1:27:44 AM #
What we need is more easy legal immigration. Our current system is broken. We cannot get the immigrant labor that we desperately need, and the immigrants cannot get here to work. Supply and demand happens whether legal or not. Workers will continue to come work, because there is work to be done. You should not need to spend five years on a waiting list to pick fruit. If my family needed the money, you can bet your ass I would cross the border and work. Sometimes, laws are bad enough that they just have to be broken.
Brownbeard | Reply
8/4/2010 2:15:36 AM #
I agree that our immigration system is broken. But the problem right now in Arizona and Texas is NOT immigrants looking for work. It is criminal maggots selling drugs, selling people, and MURDERING US citizens.
8/5/2010 12:28:33 AM #
The problem is Brad, crime is as low as it has been in 30 years in border states and cities. In 1960, AZ had 6 murders per 100K people. That peaked in the Reagan years. Then has dropped steadily for the last 16 years. Now it is 6.3. In fact, every single type of crime has dropped steadily in the past 15 years. Crime is as low as it has been since the late 70's. And violent crime is at levels compared to the 60's. The crime issue is not really an issue.http://www.disastercenter.com/crime/azcrime.htm
8/5/2010 12:45:52 AM #
I said criminal maggots, not just CRIME. The statistics you refer to are numbers that represent SOME of the crimes. I didn't see kidnapping, posession/sale of narcotics, or human trafficking in those figures. So you are saying crime is NOT an issue? Arizona Sheriff Paul Babeu: Babeu described how his deputies were outmanned and outgunned by the cartel smugglers who increasingly operate using military tactics and weapons. "A wide corridor of Arizona from the border North to the outskirts of Phoenix is effectively controlled by the cartels. We do not have control of this area." - Babeu I think that you might think differently if you lived in this area.
Add comment
Cancel reply to comment
Get notified when a new post is published.